Proxy Video Editing (Bait-n-Switch) Method with Adobe Premiere

Posted on 6/24/2013 2:37:00 AM

Proxy Editing is a great way to edit video in draft cuts even with a low power processor laptop/ultrabook.

(I did not invent this method but I have been editing this way since Premiere 4.2 with laptops. Just would like to share the experience.)
 
With today's high compression complex codecs like AVCHD or MPEG4 H.264, editing with NLE would be challenging on a lower power laptop CPU. The complex encoding scheme makes scrubbing on timeline less responsive. With Proxy files, editing could be done on low power laptops. It also makes possible with DSLR .MOV files doing Same Day Edit at weddings/events with a regular laptop too.
 
To have proxy editing, all source files are needed to be transcoded to a faster codec. These are my choices
 
AVI - Microsoft Video 1
MOV - Sorenson 3.0 or Photo JPEG codec.
 
A tool allowing batch transcoding is needed. Grass Valley Procoder, or Adobe Media Encoder (AME) both allows Watch Folder setup. It's a quick way for automatic batch conversion. With AME, first we need to create an Export profile. For example, a Quicktime MOV preset can be set as follow
 
Video Codec : Photo - JPEG
Quality : between 50 to 100. Higher quality takes longer time to transcode.
Width and Height : 640x360 or 320x180. Higher resolution takes longer time to transcode. It could be as low as 256x144 for quicker conversion.
Frame Rate : 29.97 or 15 for 30p. 23.976 or 12 for 24p. It could be as low as 10fps for even faster conversion.
Aspect : Square pixel.
 
For audio codec, it should match the source clip format to avoid any re-conforming of audio in Premiere Pro. For most DSLR .MOV, it will be 48khz, stereo, 16bit.
 

 
Once done, save the preset to be used with the Watch Folder setup at Adobe Media Encoder later.
 
In AME CS5.5, you can create watch folder setup at File, Create Watch Folder. Then specify the Format as QuickTime, and Preset with the one created above. You might also check the option on top for "Auto-Encode Watch Folders". This option allows any files being copied to the watch folder to kick off the transcoding process automatically. It is great for working on Same Day Edit when content from memory cards are being copied to computer.
 

 
Once the low res MOV files are transcoded, they can be imported to Premiere for editing. The resolution together with frame rate could be low. But it is only temporary and good enough for a quick rough cut.
 
When done, before rendering a full quality version of the project (on the same laptop or at desktop computer), close the Premiere project. Then rename or move away those LQ MOV files. Next time when re-opening the Premiere project, Premiere will prompt the user to locate where are the missing .MOV files. At this time, point back to the original full resolution .MOV files. This "bait-n-switch" fools Premiere to export a high quality full resolution output.
 
I have been using Grass Valley Procoder's watch folder feature to transcode .mov files. The low res files are small and very portable. It makes editing with rough cuts a lot faster and more scrubbing responsive even with a low power laptop.
 
Any comments, welcome to leave them below.

 


Comments

Posted by Kevin on 1/31/2011 2:02:00 PM Can you do this on Adobe media encoder, or is ther a setting already in there that you could just convert the files to.

Replied by LA Color Pros You can use Adobe Media Encoder to convert the video file to a smaller low quality version.
Posted by Jacob on 7/22/2011 1:07:00 AM What size and format would you recommend compacting down to when dealing with 1080p 24fps footage from a T2i? Does it make a difference where its coming from?
 
Also, after editing in Premier 4, would I simply have to Export it at a the quality of the original?
 
Thank you for the all the awesome tutorials you've posted by the way!

Replied by LA Color Pros When sizing down the video, I use Microsoft Video 1 to 320x240 (4:3 format) then adjust the aspect ratio in Premiere. Remember, this proxy version video is just for rough cut. Once you have the video edited, you would need to switch all the LQ clips back to HQ clips before exporting.
Posted by Prashant on 6/24/2013 7:45:00 PM Awesome tip. Do we have anything like for Sony vegas ??

Replied by LA Color Pros Hi Prashant, Proxy Editing is a concept. It can work with all NLE including Sony Vegas. You only need to find a tool that allows batch transcoding to convert to a low resolution files for quick edits. You can check out Handbrake or SUPER for taking care of the batch conversion job.
Posted by cgbier on 6/24/2013 8:47:00 PM I'm using MPEG Streamclip for batch transcoding. Is pretty fast. Don't know how well the Windows version is working though.

Replied by LA Color Pros Thanks for reminding me that MPEG Streamclip can do the batch encoding job too.
Posted by picturelights1 on 6/24/2013 11:55:00 PM I'm using MPEG Streamclip for batch transcoding.
 
http://www.perfectpicturelighting.com
Posted by Celso Vitorino on 6/25/2013 10:23:00 AM
Taky, thanks for the excellent tip for Adobe Premiere.
 
On the question of Vegas made ??above, Malow, a Brazilian fellow developed a script (freeware) that allows mutate proxy for the original and vice versa. Details on the links below:
 
Generate Intermediate Files (Script)
http://www.videobr.pro.br/forum/download/file.php?id=10408
 
Switcher Proxy x Original (Script)
http://www.videobr.pro.br/forum/download/file.php?id=10409
 
Details of installation, configuration and use, visit:
http://www.videobr.pro.br/forum/viewtopic.php?f=69&t=18342&st=0&sk=t&sd=a&start=90
 

Posted by James Rivera on 8/28/2014 2:04:00 AM Hey,thanks for this blog entry, though it was quite a while ago. When you use 320 x 240, how do you adjust the aspect ratio in premiere? Thanks.

Replied by LA Color Pros Thank you for visiting our blog. For 16:9 video, you can still do 320x240 and "Interpret Footage" as 1:1.2 pixel aspect ratio. Or, you can transcode to 384x216 too.
Posted by dslr uk on 6/15/2015 6:53:00 PM Hi taky, what about fcpx ?

Replied by LA Color Pros I'm sure you can do the same with FCPX. If not, FCPX sucks!
Name
Email
Email address will not be displayed.
You will be notified when you question or feedback is answered.
Message
2 + 2 =
 

Please do not use this Comment Form for customer service or warranty inquiry. Click on Contact Us!

Return to blog home page       Subscribe Mailing List

Latest Activity

Comments on "How to Repair DSLR .MOV on Corrupted SD Card"

"You have helped a lot. Thanks a lot for this blog. Couldn't have got the files back without this blog...."

Posted by Sooraj
on 8/6/2017
Read More

Blog Archive

2017
Oct 5    Digital Delivery for Event Filmmaker at BVA 
Jul 23    Audio Acquisition Comparison 
May 8    Should I Offer Wedding Video Raw Footage? 
Apr 19    Awesome RODE PinMic  
Apr 18    Wedding Film Project Delivered using TakyBox vs Vimeo Pro  Feature Article
Jan 12    No More Sandbags 
Jan 2    TakyBox V3 Official Release  Feature Article
 
2016
Dec 28    External Backup System with Harddrive Dock 
Dec 18    ALL-I vs IPB 
Dec 17    Cloud Storage vs Cloud Backup 
Dec 14    The Wedding Film Retreat  Feature Article
Nov 28    Playback Wedding Film with TakyBox on Amazon Fire  
Nov 24    Sole Proprietor, DBA, LLC, S-Corp...  Feature Article
Oct 12    Copyright Infringement Strike  
Oct 11    What Couples Should Be Looking for When Hiring a Wedding Videographer? (1)
Sep 29    Special Discount for High Profile Wedding Cinema Workshop 
Sep 9    TakyBox for the Spanish Audience 
Aug 24    Cables Required to Record Sound Feed from DJ 
Aug 21    Photoshop, Bringing People Closer Together. 
Aug 16    Color Tone Of Your Film 
Aug 5    Flxing Flickering LED Issue 
Jul 8    Falcon Media to Discontinue Blank BluRay Media Production 
Jun 8    Backup and Editing Workflow 
Jun 7    Mic'ing the Bride  Feature Article
May 26    A Windy Wedding Day 
May 24    Trick out the Dual Channel Quick Charger with LCD Display 
Apr 11    2-Day Cine School with Tom Antos 
Apr 1    Summit for Event Filmmakers at San Clemente, CA 
Mar 7    Data Recovery Presentation at WPPI 2016 
Feb 29    Popular license music sites  Feature Article
Jan 28    Introducing TB Dongle  Feature Article
Jan 4    InFocus Video Conference 2016 
Jan 1    Professional DVD and BluRay Production by Yourself (4) Feature Article
 
2015
2014
2013
2012
2011
2010
2009
2008
2007
 

Blog Home
Join Mailing List